I have a question. If we catch all the fish in the pond at the house we bought, will they come back? (for instance, I bought the death house) I was scared that if i catch all the fish at my house that there will be no more fish in it. Does your pond replensih with fish, or are they gone once you catch them all? And... If you enter your house in the ratings in the commons, people will probably fish at your house to see what kinds of fish you got. I've done it. Do the fish come back, after they've all been caught? I need 5 cuddlefish for a tapestry recipe. I know the Death House has cuddlefish.